We discussed the concept today. Definition of equipoise
The state in which there is no clear knowledge of the answer to a question. I find myself resting in this state for most of my life about many questions, like does God exist? Do I give dollar bills to street performers? Is it better to read the Times or a Pulitzer Prize winning novel?
A professor told us today that watchful waiting is often the wisest decision for these times. Wait for the next big randomized control trial to confirm the last, for a trial even bigger and well-designed than the ones before.
Then there are those moments when I finally do decide: Yes, I WILL give dollar bills (but not five's) to street performers and the homeless, but only when they seem to me at first glance as 'good' people; Yes, reading the Times IS better than reading a novel, but only on Fri, Sat, Sun when I get my Weekender on my doorstep; Yes, there IS a God!
I have to say these are moments worth celebrating, the endings of a dark yet wonderfully confused time full of possibilities. With each of these moments I feel a bit older, more chiseled and hardened. It's relieving to finally stand for something. Although it's hard to attribute these moments to randomized controlled trials at all, or even to personal experience. Perhaps they were the product of my impatience at being young and malleable, although I hope it was more magical than that.
More likely I decided when I was finally cornered by circumstances: when faced with street performers 3-4 times a day, when faced with the choice of reading material on every subway ride, when overhearing discussions about God and the lack thereof over beers and martinis one too many times. I like that feeling though, of only deciding when forced to. It's a bit like being shoved into the role of a leader not because I chose it, but because it chose me. Yes, to be chosen by my choices. In some ways that's the only way I would be convinced my choices were right. How else could I be justified in breaking clinical equipoise without randomized controlled trials?
One day I will miss the darkness of this state of questioning. It is, after all, the realm I was always drawn to: the frontiers of knowledge that the annoyingly bright headlights of science have not yet penetrated. But I suppose my choices, even after they're made, unlike science - or like science for that matter, sheds no additional light into these beautiful chasms at all. It's comforting to know that the darkness will always be there, and that all I will ever do is to paint my own stars within it.
Hello! And a belated Boston cream pie birthday cake
10 years ago